Files @ f734d107296e
Branch filter:

Location: kallithea/docs/usage/performance.rst - annotation

f734d107296e 5.2 KiB text/prs.fallenstein.rst Show Source Show as Raw Download as Raw
Mads Kiilerich
auth: for default permissions, use existing explicit query result values instead of following dot references in ORM result objects

There has been reports of spurious crashes on resolving references like
.repository from Permissions:

File ".../kallithea/lib/auth.py", line 678, in __wrapper
if self.check_permissions(user):
File ".../kallithea/lib/auth.py", line 718, in check_permissions
return user.has_repository_permission_level(repo_name, self.required_perm)
File ".../kallithea/lib/auth.py", line 450, in has_repository_permission_level
actual_perm = self.permissions['repositories'].get(repo_name)
File ".../kallithea/lib/vcs/utils/lazy.py", line 41, in __get__
value = self._func(obj)
File ".../kallithea/lib/auth.py", line 442, in permissions
return self.__get_perms(user=self, cache=False)
File ".../kallithea/lib/auth.py", line 498, in __get_perms
return compute(user_id, user_is_admin)
File ".../kallithea/lib/auth.py", line 190, in _cached_perms_data
r_k = perm.UserRepoToPerm.repository.repo_name
File ".../sqlalchemy/orm/attributes.py", line 285, in __get__
return self.impl.get(instance_state(instance), dict_)
File ".../sqlalchemy/orm/attributes.py", line 721, in get
value = self.callable_(state, passive)
File ".../sqlalchemy/orm/strategies.py", line 710, in _load_for_state
% (orm_util.state_str(state), self.key)

sqlalchemy.orm.exc.DetachedInstanceError: Parent instance <UserRepoToPerm at ...> is not bound to a Session; lazy load operation of attribute 'repository' cannot proceed (Background on this error at: http://sqlalche.me/e/bhk3)

Permissions are cached between requests: SA result records are stored in in
beaker.cache.sql_cache_short and resued in following requests after the initial
session as been removed. References in Permission objects would usually give
lazy lookup ... but not outside the original session, where we would get an
error like this.

Permissions are indeed implemented/used incorrectly. That might explain a part
of the problem. Even if not fully explaining or fixing this problem, it is
still worth fixing:

Permissions are fetched from the database using Session().query with multiple
class/table names (joined together in way that happens to match the references
specified in the table definitions) - including Repository. The results are
thus "structs" with selected objects. If repositories always were retrieved
using this selected repository, everything would be fine. In some places, this
was what we did.

But in some places, the code happened to do what was more intuitive: just use
.repository and rely on "lazy" resolving. SA was not aware that this one
already was present in the result struct, and would try to fetch it again. Best
case, that could be inefficient. Worst case, it would fail as we see here.

Fix this by only querying from one table but use the "joinedload" option to
also fetch other referenced tables in the same select. (This might
inefficiently return the main record multiple times ... but that was already
the case with the previous approach.)

This change is thus doing multiple things with circular dependencies that can't
be split up in minor parts without taking detours:

The existing repository join like:
.join((Repository, UserGroupRepoToPerm.repository_id == Repository.repo_id))
is thus replaced by:
.options(joinedload(UserGroupRepoToPerm.repository))

Since we only are doing Session.query() on one table, the results will be of
that type instead of "structs" with multiple objects. If only querying for
UserRepoToPerm this means:
- perm.UserRepoToPerm.repository becomes perm.repository
- perm.Permission.permission_name looked at the explicitly queried Permission
in the result struct - instead it should look in the the dereferenced
repository as perm.permission.permission_name
fa88997aa421
fa88997aa421
fa88997aa421
22a3fa3c4254
fa88997aa421
fa88997aa421
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
5d12768a0aa1
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
fa88997aa421
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
6afa528ee30e
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
fa88997aa421
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
fb0417c65c64
fb0417c65c64
fb0417c65c64
fb0417c65c64
fb0417c65c64
fb0417c65c64
fb0417c65c64
fb0417c65c64
fb0417c65c64
fa88997aa421
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
8b8edfc25856
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
8b8edfc25856
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
fa88997aa421
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
d6942b2b421c
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
49c82acd30b2
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
d6942b2b421c
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
d6942b2b421c
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
d6942b2b421c
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
d79f3505549e
4e6dfdb3fa01
4e6dfdb3fa01
4e6dfdb3fa01
4e6dfdb3fa01
4e6dfdb3fa01
4e6dfdb3fa01
d6942b2b421c
4e6dfdb3fa01
4e6dfdb3fa01
4e6dfdb3fa01
4cd84f4f28fb
4cd84f4f28fb
778f7ae3b6eb
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
d02c715e2805
61954577a0df
61954577a0df
692dddf298e2
692dddf298e2
61954577a0df
692dddf298e2
692dddf298e2
692dddf298e2
692dddf298e2
61954577a0df
61954577a0df
61954577a0df
61954577a0df
61954577a0df
61954577a0df
61954577a0df
61954577a0df
61954577a0df
61954577a0df
61954577a0df
61954577a0df
61954577a0df
61954577a0df
61954577a0df
692dddf298e2
61954577a0df
61954577a0df
61954577a0df
692dddf298e2
692dddf298e2
692dddf298e2
692dddf298e2
692dddf298e2
692dddf298e2
692dddf298e2
fbbe80e3322b
778f7ae3b6eb
.. _performance:

================================
Optimizing Kallithea performance
================================

When serving a large amount of big repositories, Kallithea can start performing
slower than expected. Because of the demanding nature of handling large amounts
of data from version control systems, here are some tips on how to get the best
performance.


Fast storage
------------

Kallithea is often I/O bound, and hence a fast disk (SSD/SAN) and plenty of RAM
is usually more important than a fast CPU.


Caching
-------

Tweak beaker cache settings in the ini file. The actual effect of that is
questionable.

.. note::

    Beaker has no upper bound on cache size and will never drop any caches. For
    memory cache, the only option is to regularly restart the worker process.
    For file cache, it must be cleaned manually, as described in the `Beaker
    documentation <https://beaker.readthedocs.io/en/latest/sessions.html#removing-expired-old-sessions>`_::

        find data/cache -type f -mtime +30 -print -exec rm {} \;


Database
--------

SQLite is a good option when having a small load on the system. But due to
locking issues with SQLite, it is not recommended to use it for larger
deployments.

Switching to MySQL or PostgreSQL will result in an immediate performance
increase. A tool like SQLAlchemyGrate_ can be used for migrating to another
database platform.


Horizontal scaling
------------------

Scaling horizontally means running several Kallithea instances and let them
share the load. That can give huge performance benefits when dealing with large
amounts of traffic (many users, CI servers, etc.). Kallithea can be scaled
horizontally on one (recommended) or multiple machines.

It is generally possible to run WSGI applications multithreaded, so that
several HTTP requests are served from the same Python process at once. That can
in principle give better utilization of internal caches and less process
overhead.

One danger of running multithreaded is that program execution becomes much more
complex; programs must be written to consider all combinations of events and
problems might depend on timing and be impossible to reproduce.

Kallithea can't promise to be thread-safe, just like the embedded Mercurial
backend doesn't make any strong promises when used as Kallithea uses it.
Instead, we recommend scaling by using multiple server processes.

Web servers with multiple worker processes (such as ``mod_wsgi`` with the
``WSGIDaemonProcess`` ``processes`` parameter) will work out of the box.

In order to scale horizontally on multiple machines, you need to do the
following:

    - Each instance's ``data`` storage needs to be configured to be stored on a
      shared disk storage, preferably together with repositories. This ``data``
      dir contains template caches, sessions, whoosh index and is used for
      task locking (so it is safe across multiple instances). Set the
      ``cache_dir``, ``index_dir``, ``beaker.cache.data_dir``, ``beaker.cache.lock_dir``
      variables in each .ini file to a shared location across Kallithea instances
    - If using several Celery instances,
      the message broker should be common to all of them (e.g.,  one
      shared RabbitMQ server)
    - Load balance using round robin or IP hash, recommended is writing LB rules
      that will separate regular user traffic from automated processes like CI
      servers or build bots.


Serve static files directly from the web server
-----------------------------------------------

With the default ``static_files`` ini setting, the Kallithea WSGI application
will take care of serving the static files from ``kallithea/public/`` at the
root of the application URL.

The actual serving of the static files is very fast and unlikely to be a
problem in a Kallithea setup - the responses generated by Kallithea from
database and repository content will take significantly more time and
resources.

To serve static files from the web server, use something like this Apache config
snippet::

        Alias /images/ /srv/kallithea/kallithea/kallithea/public/images/
        Alias /css/ /srv/kallithea/kallithea/kallithea/public/css/
        Alias /js/ /srv/kallithea/kallithea/kallithea/public/js/
        Alias /codemirror/ /srv/kallithea/kallithea/kallithea/public/codemirror/
        Alias /fontello/ /srv/kallithea/kallithea/kallithea/public/fontello/

Then disable serving of static files in the ``.ini`` ``app:main`` section::

        static_files = false

If using Kallithea installed as a package, you should be able to find the files
under ``site-packages/kallithea``, either in your Python installation or in your
virtualenv. When upgrading, make sure to update the web server configuration
too if necessary.

It might also be possible to improve performance by configuring the web server
to compress responses (served from static files or generated by Kallithea) when
serving them. That might also imply buffering of responses - that is more
likely to be a problem; large responses (clones or pulls) will have to be fully
processed and spooled to disk or memory before the client will see any
response. See the documentation for your web server.


.. _SQLAlchemyGrate: https://github.com/shazow/sqlalchemygrate